Choosing the right payroll software is a key decision for any business, especially as you scale your team or navigate complex HR needs. Two of the most widely recognized payroll solutions on the market today are Gusto and Paychex. While both platforms offer full-service payroll, tax compliance, and employee benefits support, they cater to different business preferences and budgets. 

Gusto is known for its tech-forward simplicity and transparent pricing, while Paychex offers a more traditional, hands-on approach with a broader range of features. In this guide, we’ll break down the key differences between Gusto and Paychex to help you determine which payroll platform is the better fit for your needs.

Quick Comparison Table: Gusto vs. Paychex

Feature	Gusto	Paychex
Base Price	$49/month + $6 per employee	$39/month + $5 per employee*
Per Pay Run Charges	No	Possibly Yes (check with provider)
Payroll Coverage	All 50 states	All 50 states
Benefits Admin	Included in base (limited)	Available as add-ons or proprietary
HR Support	Premium tier only	Included in some lower-tier plans
Mobile Payroll App	No	Yes (Paychex Flex app)
Customer Support	Business hours only	24/7 with dedicated specialist
Scalability	Small to mid-sized businesses	Small to large enterprises
Custom Plans	Transparent pricing tiers	Custom quotes for higher tiers

Pricing may vary depending on whether it’s per pay period or per month – always confirm with Paychex.

Features and Services: All-in-One or Add-On Heavy?

Both Gusto and Paychex offer full-service payroll across all 50 U.S. states, including direct deposit, tax filing, and new hire reporting. However, the way they package their features differs significantly. Gusto includes several HR and benefits administration tools in its base plan, such as onboarding workflows, org charts, and some insurance options. In contrast, Paychex often charges extra for similar features, offering them through modular add-ons or higher-tier plans.

HR Services

Paychex Flex also supports more complex payroll setups, such as job costing, contractor payments, and retirement plan integration. It even offers a solopreneur plan and a full PEO (Professional Employer Organization) service for larger businesses. One standout feature from Paychex is its dedicated HR advisor support, available even in some lower-tier plans—something Gusto only offers in its Premium tier. Ultimately, Paychex is ideal for businesses needing depth and flexibility, while Gusto works best for those wanting an all-in-one package at a predictable price.

Pricing: Flat-Rate Simplicity vs. Variable Costs

Paychex doesn’t publicly list prices on its main site for most plans, but they do advertise a starting package called Paychex Flex Essentials, aimed at businesses with up to 19 employees. That package is priced at around $39 per month plus $5 per employee. This starting price is actually slightly lower base fee than Gusto’s $49 base, making Paychex appear very competitive. 

However, important to note is how Paychex charges: historically, Paychex (like ADP) often charges that base and per-employee fee for each payroll run (each pay period), not just per month. For example, if you run weekly payrolls, you might pay $39 * 4 per month. 

Some sources indicate the $39+$5 is a monthly fee, but small print may reveal it’s per pay run. Gusto, on the other hand, charges $49+$6 per month regardless of how many times you run payroll in that month. This means that for weekly payrolls or frequent off-cycle payrolls, Paychex can become much more expensive than Gusto. On the flip side, if you only run one payroll a month, 

Paychex’s pricing could be quite comparable. Always clarify with Paychex how the fee is applied. Beyond the starter plan, Paychex offers higher tiers (Select, Pro, etc.) which are custom-quoted and can include more features like a dedicated specialist, more HR tools, garnishment handling, etc. Those can increase the cost significantly.

User Experience and Ease of Use

Gusto tends to beat Paychex in user-friendliness. Paychex Flex is a powerful platform, but some small business owners find it a bit less intuitive. It has improved with a modern web interface and mobile app, but because Paychex offers so many services, the interface can have more options and settings to navigate. 

Gusto’s design is simpler by virtue of focusing on the most common needs of small businesses. That said, Paychex offers a mobile app for administrators to run payroll (the Paychex Flex app), which is something Gusto lacks. This means if being able to process payroll via smartphone is critical, Paychex has an advantage there.

HR Support and Compliance Guidance

For businesses that value hands-on HR support, Paychex has a clear edge. Many of its plans include access to an HR support center, compliance alerts, and even a dedicated HR consultant who can guide your business through sensitive employee issues, legal compliance, and workforce planning. This kind of support is often essential for growing businesses navigating complex labor laws.

Gusto includes basic HR tools like document storage, onboarding checklists, and org charts in its core plans. However, access to certified HR experts and templates for handbooks or performance reviews is limited to the Premium tier. While this tier still offers good value, it’s not as accessible for budget-conscious businesses. If HR support is a priority, Paychex offers more robust services across more plan levels. If you’re comfortable with a more self-service model, Gusto is a great fit.

Customer Service and Support Availability

Paychex is known for very strong customer support and even assigns a dedicated payroll specialist or relationship manager to many of its clients. 

• They also have 24/7 support availability. This level of support can be reassuring – for example, if an issue arises on Friday night, Paychex support is just a call away. Gusto’s support, while high quality, doesn’t have that round-the-clock availability. 
• Some reviews mention that Paychex’s customer service feels more “hands-on,” sometimes even proactively assisting with compliance tasks or providing courtesy calls. 
• On the other hand, a few small businesses might feel that level of involvement isn’t necessary and prefer the self-service nature of Gusto with occasional support as needed.

Scalability and Business Fit

Other comparisons: Paychex, like ADP, can scale to larger businesses more easily than Gusto. They offer services like workers’ comp payment service, state unemployment insurance management, and more specialized payroll reports. Paychex also has a solid track record and reliability. 

FitSmallBusiness’s comparison gave Paychex a slightly higher score for very comprehensive feature set but noted that Gusto edged it out in overall value for small business needs. Typically, Gusto wins on simplicity and cost for small businesses, whereas Paychex might win on depth of features and personalized service, which can be overkill for a small operation but valuable for a larger one.

Final Verdict: Should You Choose Gusto or Paychex?

Choose Gusto if you want an easy-to-use, affordable payroll and HR platform with transparent pricing and solid core features. It’s perfect for startups and small teams that prefer a streamlined, tech-forward experience.
Choose Paychex if you need hands-on support, advanced HR services, or scalability for a growing workforce. It’s especially beneficial for businesses that require 24/7 support, compliance guidance, or custom plan flexibility.

Simplify your finances—book a free consultation today!